There is an ancient Chinese curse
that says “May you live interesting times.” In fact it’s probably not Chinese,
and probably not ancient, but it certainly describes what we woke up to on
Friday morning: the biggest political shock since 1945 when Labour swept to
power after everyone expected Churchill to win the election, and the biggest political
miscalculation since Eden’s decision to invade Suez in 1956. This is such a significant turn of events
that we can’t shut our eyes to it in church, so I want to reflect theologically
on it this morning . I have to put my cards on the table and say that what I
felt on Friday morning was a mixture of shock, anger, sadness and fear. Shock –
because, although everyone thought the vote would be close, no-one actually
expected it to go this way; anger – because there has been so much
disinformation and downright lying which I believe has deceived people; anger
because nearly half the nation has been pulled unwillingly into a place we
didn’t choose; and fear, because we simply don’t know what will happen now.
Sadness, because any break down of relationships is sad. But I’ve had a couple
of days to reflect and to put my own feelings to one side and to look at where
we find ourselves through biblical lenses.
The three big issues that the
referendum was fought over were immigration, sovereignty, and the economy. What
has been uncovered is the deep division in the UK: between the metropolitan
areas and the rest of the country – London and the rest of England; between
England and Wales and Scotland and Northern Ireland. It seems that the prospect
of the UK splitting apart is again on the table: Scotland away from England and
even Northern Ireland uniting with the Irish Republic. Already there have been
100s of applications in NI for Irish EU passports. Division between young and old, between
middle class and working class, between rich and poor, between the ‘elite’ and
‘the man in the street’. And that has left me chastened to some extent. Because
I have identified so much with the affluent, politically literate metropolitan
population that I have dismissed the very real concerns of those who feel hard
done-by, ignored and trodden over.
What will happen now. Probably
tomorrow petrol prices will rise by 1 or 2p a litre. (I wonder if we will
revert to gallons?) Those with pension and other investments will probably see
their value drop by up to 10%, and those 1000s of UK pensioners who live in the
EU will be harder hit. Those of us who go abroad for a holiday will find it
more expensive. And already EU citizens living here are beginning to wonder if
they are welcome.
A particularly unwelcome reaction
is from ISIS who are rejoicing, according to The Times, over what they see as
the gradual break up of Europe. And Vladimir Putin is reported to be rubbing
his hands in glee at the prospect of a weaker Europe.
But we are where we are; we can’t
go back, and as one German politician has said, “Out is out.” So now we must
look forward with hope and build a new future.
In an article in The Guardian on
Friday the columnist Owen James said that immigration was the prism through
which many people had viewed the referendum. And I think he’s right. Many
working class people have felt overlooked and pushed aside, and helpless to do
anything about what they see as the threat of unlimited immigration, in spite
of the arguments that the majority of immigrants from the EU and elsewhere are
hard-working, tax-paying, law-abiding people. The UK is often described as a
tolerant nation, where people of all races and cultures are welcomed. And maybe
we are, but beneath that there seems to be great fear and resentment. In the
bible God told his people to remember that they were immigrants. Each year at
the harvest festival they were to take their gifts with the words, “My father
was a wandering Aramean” (Deut 26:5). And because they were descended from a
wandering nomad, and because they were a people delivered from slavery they
were to welcome the alien among them. Several times in the psalms it is said
that ‘God watches over the alien’ (Ps 146:9).
Now I think that the British, by and large, are compassionate towards
those that suffer. I am proud that this government has consistently kept up its
level of overseas aid – even if not all of that ends up in the right hands. But
it’s a sign that we care. And if those among us who are from the EU or further
afield are feeling nervous then as a church we must reassure them and make them
know they are welcome. The bible uses the image of pilgrimage to describe our
journey of faith – we are all pilgrims and strangers in this world, and as such
we should accept those who are among us, especially those who are in the
community of faith, but also all people that we live alongside. The church has
a role in speaking peace and reassurance to white working-class English people
as much as it does to Polish workers and Syrian refugees. And at the very least
we need to pray for the unity of our nation, and that division and hatred won’t
just be covered over but healed.
It’s sometimes been said of
immigrants to the UK, “They don’t belong here.” The question this referendum
has uncovered is ‘Where do we belong?’ Where does our loyalty lie? Who
is in control? Where is sovereignty located – in parliament, in the monarchy,
in Brussels? What exactly does sovereignty mean? The word ‘sovereign’ comes,
ironically from an Italian word sovrano,
which is derived from the Latin super
meaning ‘above’. So a sovereign is a supreme ruler or head. Since the 17th
century the power of the British monarch has been limited by parliament, so
sovereignty has been shared between the 2 institutions. Every international
body that the UK has been part of has involved trading a bit of sovereignty in order to belong to it: The UN, NATO
– both of which can take authority to direct our armed forces in localised
conflict areas – and the EU. Along with sovereignty has been the issue of
democracy.
Ironically the result of the
referendum has put the majority of the country at odds with the majority in
parliament. About 500 out 650 MPs supported the UK remaining. It’s going to be
interesting to see how our sovereign parliament acts to carry out a policy that
it disagrees with. More ironic, to me at least, is the fact that holding a
referendum is not a very British thing to do in the first place. In most
important decisions, such as the vote on same-sex marriage, it was parliament
that decided whereas in Ireland and in France that issue was decided by a
referendum.
So where do we belong? To whom or
to what do we give our loyalty? Who is, or should be, in control?The prophets
in the OT looked forward increasingly clearly to a kingdom that would be
established where God was king. Unlike the empires that came and went – the
Assyrian, Babylonian, Persian, Greek, Roman Empires (later the British Empire)
– this kingdom would never end. In the dream that K Nebuchadnezzar had, retold
and interpreted by Daniel, this kingdom would be like a rock that filled the
whole earth. And it’s this kingdom that
Jesus started to proclaim as soon as he began his public ministry. “The kingdom
of God is near. Repent and believe the good news.” His whole ministry was given
over to proclaiming the kingdom through words and actions: parables, miracles,
exorcisms. And this was a kingdom that was focussed on him – the king of the
kingdom, yet a king who would be rejected, betrayed and crucified. St Paul
writing to the Corinthians says that such a king is a stumbling block to Jews –
who were looking for a heroic messiah to deliver them from the Romans – and
foolishness to the Greeks – who looked for a great philosopher. The writer to
the Hebrews, reflecting on the temporary nature of life on earth, says that
‘here we do not have an enduring city’, and Peter, writing in his first letter
to believers scattered round Asia Minor (modern Turkey) because of persecution,
addresses them as ‘strangers in the world’. When Jesus faced Pontius Pilate,
the representative of the greatest earthly power – the Roman emperor – he said,
“My kingdom is not of this world…You are right in saying I am a king…”
So when it comes to questions of
sovereignty and belonging, to whom do we give our loyalty and allegiance, and
where do we belong. As Christians we must echo Paul’s words when he says, “Our
citizenship (using a Roman term) is
in heaven. And we eagerly await a Saviour from there, the Lord Jesus Christ…”
(Phil 3:20). For me, that means that I don’t get too hung up about earthly
sovereignty. Jesus was prepared to accept the earthly sovereignty of Caesar
when he famously said, “Give to Caesar what is Caesar’s and to God what is
God’s.” The example our Queen gives is the best one as she recognises that we
are all ultimately under the authority of God. She has been scrupulous in
maintaining her constitutional neutrality in the EU
debate, even when The Sun tried to imply her support for the Leave campaign. We
may never know what her personal thoughts have been on the matter. The question
of belonging is important, though. As Christians we belong to a kingdom that
has no geographical borders, whose government is on the shoulders of King
Jesus, whose entry requirements are through a narrow gate, but at the same time
open to all who will pass through that gate – Jesus himself.
One of the complaints about the EU
has always been that it’s full of ‘faceless bureaucrats’, and that it’s
impossible to relate to an MEP because the European constituencies are so big –
the whole of London, for example. The parish system of the C of E locates the
church in a small area that allows us to know who lives here, and them to know
us. When I walk around in my dog collar people, round here at least, know I’m
the Rector (even if they call me Vicar!). Through the local church we can help
people to have a sense of belonging to a kingdom that has no borders, because
it’s the local church that is the ‘shop window’ of that kingdom. I think that
should give us a real mission opportunity – particularly to those who feel that
they are ignored or overlooked by the big structures and institutions.
One of the slogans used by Boris
Johnson and others has been ‘Take back control’. It’s a powerful slogan, but
like most slogans fairly meaningless. As a nation we British don’t like being
told what to do – by our own politicians, let alone by foreigners – even our close
ally the USA. Some years ago Nicy and I took a group from our previous church
to Israel, and I noticed that as soon as British tourists got off the coach
they would scatter and find their own way round, whereas American and Japanese
tourists would stick together, all wearing the same hats and moving round like
a flock of sheep. Who is in control? Is it the UK parliament or the EU
institutions. I wonder how many people have actually bothered to find out how
the EU works, through its elected Parliament, its Council of Ministers – each
from their own member country, through its Commission – a kind of civil
service, or its Court. Some have talked about our independence from foreign
control as we can completely cut ourselves off from the outside world. Well, the
only country that has done that successfully is North Korea. From a theological
viewpoint, the question of control becomes THIS: ‘How much control of our lives
do we allow the Lord to have? There is a danger in valuing independence as a
concept so highly that we put ourselves as individuals at the centre: not
Brussel, not Westminster – it’s up to me what I do. Jesus looks for people who
will allow him to be in control.
We’ve been thinking about wealth
and how we handle money recently. Jesus had a lot to say about it. The EU was
founded as a Common Market to allow trade without tariffs. It would be very sad
and a great shame if we found ourselves locked out of the single market.
Ironically, if we do join the single market again, like Norway, we will still have
to pay a wacking fee and allow free movement of goods, services and labour as
Norway does. The
bible has little to say about
modern international trade and the sophisticated economies of today’s world.
What it does talk about is honesty in selling, not lending at extortionate
rates of interest, not hoarding wealth, and being generous. Where is our
ultimate security? I said earlier that there is much fear around today because
people don’t know what will happen to our economy – on which so much else depends.
All the signs are that in the short-term we will experience a significant
contraction in the economy. And that forces us to consider ‘Where is my
security?’ If my pension fund contracts, if the value of my house goes down or
my mortgage increases where is my faith and trust? And of course that applies
to us as a whole church: since we urge people to give in proportion to their
income, if that income goes down we have to accept that the church’s income
also goes down. This is where we need to trust God, and to encourage one
another.
Finally, where do we go from here?
No-one is quite sure. Never has it been more important to pray for our
political leaders in the UK and EU as they chart a course through new waters.
Using that metaphor let’s pray for our David Cameron in these next few weeks
that he is ‘Captain of the ship’. We need to pray for the civil servants and
others who will spend years now unpicking the 1000s of laws and regulations
that have bound us to the EU – it will be as delicate an operation as
separating Siamese twins. Let’s pray for financial leaders and institutions,
and for foreign citizens who live here and UK citizens who live the EU. And for those who voted to leave because they
feel overlooked, ignored and pushed aside.
We are where we are, and we can
only look forward now – not to a rosy nostalgic past, whether that was the last
40 years in the EU or further back.
Do not be anxious about anything, but in everything, by prayers, with
thanksgiving, present your requests to God. And the peace of God which
transcends all understanding, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ
Jesus.’
